Ataraxia meaning: the ancient Greek idea of an untroubled mind, and three routes to it

Explained

Ataraxia is one of the few Greek philosophical words that has survived into ordinary English vocabulary lists, usually glossed as "tranquillity" and left there.

That gloss is not wrong, but it hides the interesting part. Three rival ancient schools used the same word, agreed that an untroubled mind was worth having, and disagreed sharply about how to get it and whether it was the point of philosophy at all. This guide explains what the word means, what it is often mistaken for, and how the Epicureans, the Pyrrhonian sceptics and the Stoics each took a different road to the same quiet.

Quick answer

Ataraxia (Greek ataraxia, literally “untroubledness”) means a settled freedom from mental disturbance: a mind that is not shaken by fear, worry or agitation. It is not apathy, numbness or excited happiness. Epicurus made it, with freedom from bodily pain, the goal of life; the Pyrrhonian sceptics said it arrives once you suspend judgment; the Stoics preferred the word apatheia and treated calm as a by-product of virtue.

Ataraxia meaning: the ancient Greek idea of an untroubled mind, and three routes to it

What ataraxia means, and what it is not

The word, its parts, and three common misreadings

The word is built from the Greek negative prefix a- and the verb tarassein, to stir up, trouble or throw into confusion; the same verb was used of water churned by a storm or an army thrown into disorder. Ataraxia is the condition of not being stirred up. The image is still water rather than empty water: the mind is fully present, it is simply not being tossed about. Ancient writers usually spoke of the ataraxia of the soul (psyche), to set it beside the condition of the body.

Because the English glosses are so soft, the word is regularly misread. Three readings are worth ruling out before going further, because each of them would have puzzled the ancient authors who used it.

  • Not apathy or indifference. The person with ataraxia is not someone who has stopped caring about friends, justice or the truth. Epicurus put friendship near the top of the goods of life, and the Stoics demanded active duty to others. What disappears is the turmoil, not the care.
  • Not numbness or sedation. Ataraxia was supposed to be reached by thinking clearly, not by dulling thought. A drugged or exhausted mind is quiet in the wrong way, and none of the three schools would have counted it.
  • Not happiness as excitement. The modern picture of happiness as a high, a thrill or a peak experience is close to the opposite of ataraxia. The Greek ideal is steadiness: a condition you can stay in, rather than a feeling that rises and falls.

Ataraxia belongs to the ancient conversation about how to live, the same conversation that later feeds into existentialism. If you are coming at the ancients from Camus, Sartre or Kierkegaard, our guide Existentialism for Readers: three doors into the movement shows where these older questions about fear, death and freedom resurface in modern dress.

One word, three schools: how each reached ataraxia

Epicureans, Pyrrhonian sceptics and Stoics compared

Most short definitions stop at “Epicurean and Stoic tranquillity”, as if the two schools meant the same thing. They did not, and the third user of the word, the Pyrrhonian sceptic, is usually left out entirely. The table sets the three routes side by side before each is explained in turn.

SchoolStatus of ataraxiaHow you reach itKey source
EpicureansThe goal itself, together with aponia (freedom from bodily pain)By removing false beliefs, above all fear of the gods and fear of death, and by limiting desiresEpicurus, Letter to Menoeceus (preserved in Diogenes Laertius, Lives, Book 10)
Pyrrhonian scepticsNot aimed at directly; it turns up unexpectedlyBy suspending judgment (epoche) on whether things are by nature good or badSextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism, Book 1
StoicsA consequence, not the aim; the aim is virtueBy correcting false judgments so that the passions do not arise; the preferred term is apatheiaEpictetus, Discourses; Seneca, On Tranquillity of Mind
Ataraxia in three ancient schools

Epicurus: ataraxia as the goal, won by losing false fears

The Letter to Menoeceus and the fear of death

For Epicurus (341 to 270 BCE) the goal of life is pleasure, but he defined the highest pleasure in a way that surprises people who know only the modern word “epicure”. In the Letter to Menoeceus he says that when he calls pleasure the goal he does not mean the pleasures of the profligate but the absence of pain in the body and of trouble in the soul. Freedom from bodily pain is aponia; freedom from mental trouble is ataraxia. Together they make the blessed life, and once you have them nothing more is needed. These are what later writers called the “static” pleasures, as opposed to the moving pleasures of eating, drinking or being entertained.

The main obstacles to ataraxia, on Epicurus’s account, are false beliefs. People fear the gods because they imagine them as angry and meddling; Epicurus held that gods exist but are blessed, untroubled beings who do not intervene in human affairs, so they are nothing to fear. (The famous riddle about evil that bears his name is a separate matter; our page on the Epicurean paradox and why Epicurus probably never wrote it explains the source problem.) People fear death; Epicurus argued that death is nothing to us, because when we exist death is not present, and when death is present we no longer exist. There is no one left to whom it could be bad.

The cure also involved desire. Epicurus sorted desires into natural and necessary ones (food, shelter, friendship), natural but unnecessary ones (luxurious food), and empty ones (fame, power, unlimited wealth). The empty ones have no natural limit, so pursuing them guarantees disturbance. A simple life with friends, he argued, is not a sacrifice made for the sake of calm; it is what calm consists in.

The Pyrrhonian sceptics and the painter who threw his sponge

Suspending judgment in Sextus Empiricus

The Pyrrhonian sceptics took their name from Pyrrho of Elis, a contemporary of Epicurus who left no writings. Our main source is Sextus Empiricus, a Greek doctor and philosopher usually dated to the second century CE, whose Outlines of Pyrrhonism sets out the method. The sceptic sets opposing arguments and appearances against each other, finds them equally balanced, and so suspends judgment (epoche). Ataraxia, Sextus says, follows the suspension of judgment as a shadow follows a body.

The striking claim is that the sceptic did not get there by aiming at it. Sextus explains this with the story of the painter Apelles, who was painting a horse and could not get the foam at its mouth right. In frustration he threw at the picture the sponge he used to wipe his brushes, and the mark it left produced the effect of foam. The sceptics, Sextus says, were like this: they began by hoping to settle which appearances were true and so gain ataraxia, failed, suspended judgment, and then found that the calm they wanted had arrived by chance.

Sextus is also careful about limits. The sceptic still feels hunger, cold and pain, because those are forced on us. What he lacks is the extra layer of distress that comes from believing such things are bad by nature. So Sextus pairs ataraxia in matters of opinion with moderate feeling (metriopatheia) in matters that cannot be avoided. That is a more modest promise than the Epicurean one, and a more honest one about the body.

Why the Stoics preferred apatheia to ataraxia

Calm as a by-product of virtue

The Stoics are often credited with ataraxia, but their own key word was apatheia, freedom from the passions (pathe). A passion, in Stoic terms, is an excessive impulse that rests on a false judgment, for example that losing money or reputation is genuinely bad. Remove the judgment and the passion does not arise. As our page on what the Stoics actually taught about virtue and judgment sets out, virtue is the only good for them, and health, wealth and reputation are merely preferred. Apatheia is not the absence of all feeling: the Stoics kept a set of rational “good feelings” (eupatheiai), such as joy, caution and wishing well.

That is the crucial difference from Epicurus. For a Stoic, tranquillity is not the goal; virtue is. A wise person is untroubled because they judge correctly, but someone who practised Stoicism in order to feel calm would have the order backwards. Epictetus, the most practical of the Stoic teachers, does use the word ataraxia alongside apatheia in the Discourses, so the line between the schools is not a matter of vocabulary alone. Our guide to where to start with Epictetus, from the Enchiridion to the Discourses is the best route into how he talks about it. Seneca, writing in Latin, called the condition tranquillitas animi in his essay On Tranquillity of Mind, and remarks there that Democritus had called it euthymia.

For who these teachers were and when they lived, from Zeno in Athens to Marcus Aurelius in Rome, see our introduction to the Stoic philosophers and their surviving works. And if you want a reading plan for the whole tradition rather than a single word, Stoicism for readers: where to start with ancient philosophy gives an order that works.

Ataraxia and Yalom: Epicurus in Staring at the Sun

Ancient arguments in a modern book about death

The clearest modern place to see the Epicurean route at work is Irvin Yalom’s Staring at the Sun: Overcoming the Terror of Death (2008). Yalom, a psychiatrist who has written at length about the fear of death, turns to Epicurus as one of the oldest thinkers to treat that fear with arguments rather than reassurance. He draws directly on the argument that death is nothing to us, since where death is we are not, and on the symmetry argument: the long stretch of time before we were born did not trouble us, so the equal stretch after we die need not either. (The symmetry argument is stated most fully by the Roman Epicurean poet Lucretius, in Book 3 of On the Nature of Things.)

Yalom does not present these arguments as a complete cure. He treats them as ideas worth taking seriously, alongside the human connection and sense of a life fully lived that he discusses elsewhere in the book. That is a fair reading of Epicurus too, who wrote to friends and lived in a community, the Garden, rather than reasoning alone. Where these ideas touch on anxiety about death, it is worth saying plainly that this is philosophy, not treatment, and sits alongside professional support; in the US you can call or text 988.

How the word ataraxia drifted toward sedation

A modern afterlife, and what it shows

In the middle of the twentieth century the word took a turn its ancient users would not have recognised. When the first tranquillising drugs appeared in the 1950s, “ataractic” (also “ataraxic”) was used as a name for the class, and one antihistamine sedative was marketed as Atarax. The usage has largely faded, but it is a telling slide: a word for a calm reached by clear thinking became a word for calm produced by chemistry. That is exactly the reading, quiet as numbness, that all three ancient schools would have rejected.

What is still contested about untroubledness as a goal

Two old objections that have not gone away

The first objection is that a life aimed at untroubledness is too small. Ancient critics pressed it against Epicurus: Cicero, in Book 2 of On Ends, argued that calling the mere absence of pain the highest pleasure confuses two different things, and others asked whether a life built around avoiding disturbance leaves room for ambition, risk, public service or great love. Epicureans replied that friendship and philosophy are rich enough, and that most of what we call ambition is empty desire. The argument continues among modern readers who find the Garden admirable but suspect it of retreat.

The second question is whether Stoic and Epicurean calm are the same state at all. They look alike from outside: a steady person who is not thrown by bad news. But the Epicurean has it because they have removed false fears and settled into simple pleasures; the Stoic has it, if at all, because they judge rightly and treat virtue as the only good. The sceptic has it because they no longer hold the judgments either school relies on. Some scholars treat these as one psychological condition reached by three methods; others argue that the reasons are part of the state, so three different calms are being described.

Where to read about ataraxia in the original texts

Short primary sources first
  1. Epicurus, Letter to Menoeceus. A few pages long, preserved in Book 10 of Diogenes Laertius’s Lives of Eminent Philosophers. The best single statement of pleasure as the absence of pain and trouble, and of death as nothing to us.
  2. Lucretius, On the Nature of Things, Book 3. The Epicurean case against fearing death set out at length in Latin verse, including the symmetry argument.
  3. Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism, Book 1. The sceptic’s account of suspension of judgment, the story of Apelles, and moderate feeling in unavoidable things.
  4. Epictetus, Enchiridion and Discourses. The Stoic route, where calm follows from judging what is and is not up to us.
  5. Seneca, On Tranquillity of Mind. A Roman Stoic essay addressed to his friend Serenus, about restlessness and how to steady it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the literal meaning of ataraxia?

It means untroubledness or freedom from disturbance. The word joins the Greek negative prefix a- to a root meaning to stir up or throw into confusion, so it describes a mind that is not being churned.

Is ataraxia the same as apathy?

No. Apathy means not caring. Ataraxia means not being thrown into turmoil while still caring about friends, truth and right action. Even the Stoic word apatheia means freedom from irrational passions, not freedom from all feeling.

Is ataraxia an Epicurean or a Stoic idea?

Mainly Epicurean and Pyrrhonian. Epicurus made it part of the goal of life, and the sceptic Sextus Empiricus described it as following from suspended judgment. The Stoics preferred apatheia and treated calm as a consequence of virtue, though Epictetus uses the word ataraxia too.

What is the difference between ataraxia and aponia?

Ataraxia is freedom from trouble in the mind; aponia is freedom from pain in the body. Epicurus treated the two together as the highest, settled kind of pleasure.

How do you pronounce ataraxia?

In English it is usually said at-uh-RAK-see-uh, with the stress on the third syllable.

Does Irvin Yalom write about ataraxia?

Not under that name as a theme, but in Staring at the Sun (2008) he draws directly on Epicurus’s arguments against the fear of death, including the claim that death is nothing to us and the symmetry between the time before birth and after death.

Conclusion

Ataraxia is a steady mind, reached by three different roads

Ataraxia means untroubledness: a mind that stays clear and steady, not one that has stopped caring or been dulled. Epicurus made it, with freedom from bodily pain, the goal of life and reached it by dismantling the fears of the gods and of death. The Pyrrhonian sceptics found it arriving unbidden once they suspended judgment. The Stoics aimed at virtue and preferred the word apatheia, treating calm as what follows. Read the Letter to Menoeceus, Book 1 of Sextus, and Epictetus side by side, and the differences become the most interesting part of the word.