Existential courage explained: Tillich, Rollo May and saying yes in spite of anxiety
Existential courage is the act of affirming one's own life and choices in spite of anxiety about death, meaninglessness and guilt, rather than waiting for that anxiety to go away first.
The phrase belongs to existential theology and psychology. Its classic statement is Paul Tillich’s The Courage to Be (1952); Rollo May took it into psychotherapy, and the psychologist Salvatore Maddi later described his research on hardiness as a measurable form of it. This guide sets out what the term means, the misreadings that cling to it, how it meets Irvin Yalom’s four givens, and what critics object to.
Existential courage is saying yes to your own life while anxiety about death, meaninglessness and guilt is still present. Paul Tillich set it out in The Courage to Be (1952) as self-affirmation in spite of non-being. It is not fearlessness, a mood or a fixed trait, and it is an idea, not a treatment.

Four things existential courage is often mistaken for
The word courage pulls the idea toward the battlefield and the motivational poster, and both pulls mislead. In the existential tradition the term names a stance toward the basic conditions of a human life, not a feat. It sits within the wider approach described in our guide to what existential therapy is and where it comes from, and the books behind it are ordered in our reading order of the best existential therapy books.
- Not fearlessness. For Tillich, courage only exists where anxiety does. Someone who feels nothing about death or failure is not showing courage; they are simply untroubled.
- Not positive thinking. The tradition does not ask anyone to reframe mortality or meaninglessness as good news. The anxiety is taken as accurate: these threats are real features of existence.
- Not physical bravery. Running into a burning building can be brave without touching the questions this idea is about. Existential courage is quieter and usually invisible: a choice made, a commitment kept, a life owned.
- Not a trait you have or lack. Tillich and May treat it as something done, again and again, not a fixed endowment. Even Maddi, who measured it, argued that hardiness can be learned.
Put positively: existential courage is acting as the author of one’s life while knowing that the life will end, that no meaning is guaranteed from outside, and that one will fall short of what one could be. The anxiety does not vanish. It is carried.
Paul Tillich's The Courage to Be and the three anxieties
Tillich, a German Protestant theologian who emigrated to the United States in 1933, gave the Terry Lectures at Yale and published them as The Courage to Be in 1952. His central claim is that courage is the self-affirmation of being in spite of non-being. Non-being here is not an abstraction: it is everything that threatens to end, empty or condemn a person’s existence.
Anxiety, for Tillich, is the awareness of that threat. He distinguished it from fear: fear has a definite object that can be faced or fled, while anxiety has no object, because its object is non-being itself. He then sorted existential anxiety into three types, each with a relative and an absolute form.
| Type of anxiety | Relative form | Absolute form |
|---|---|---|
| Ontic: fate and death | Fate: the contingency of where, when and how we live | Death: the ultimate end of the self |
| Spiritual: emptiness and meaninglessness | Emptiness: particular beliefs and commitments losing their hold | Meaninglessness: the loss of any ultimate meaning |
| Moral: guilt and condemnation | Guilt: falling short of what we are called to become | Condemnation: the threat of total self-rejection |
Tillich held that this existential anxiety cannot be removed, because it belongs to being finite. What can go wrong is the response. Neurotic anxiety, in his account, is the attempt to escape non-being by shrinking one’s being: avoiding life so as to avoid its threats. Courage is the opposite move, taking the anxiety into oneself and affirming life anyway. He also traced two forms of it: the courage to be as a part, belonging to a community and its values, and the courage to be as oneself, which he linked to existentialism. The book closes on a theological note about a faith that can accept meaninglessness itself, which secular readers often set aside.
Tillich also wrote, in a separate sermon, about the difference between loneliness and solitude, a theme discussed in our page on solitude versus isolation in Tillich, Arendt and Yalom.
Rollo May's kinds of courage in The Courage to Create
Rollo May, who had studied with Tillich and counted him a friend and teacher, carried the idea into American psychotherapy. In his early book The Meaning of Anxiety (1950) he separated normal anxiety, proportionate to a real threat, from neurotic anxiety, which is out of proportion and drives repression. Courage, for May, is what lets a person act while normal anxiety is present.
In The Courage to Create (1975) May named several kinds of courage: physical, moral, social and creative. Physical courage concerns the body; moral courage, standing for what is right against pressure; social courage, risking real intimacy with another person; and creative courage, bringing new forms and meanings into being. For May, creative courage was the most important, and he did not mean only artists: a life lived on one’s own terms is a creative act too. Courage in his sense is not the absence of despair but the capacity to move ahead in spite of it.
Salvatore Maddi took a third route. With colleagues including Suzanne Kobasa he studied managers at Illinois Bell Telephone through the upheaval of the telephone industry’s deregulation, and described hardiness as a pattern of commitment, control and challenge that seemed to protect some employees from the effects of stress. In later writing Maddi explicitly called hardiness the operationalization of existential courage: the attitudes that let people turn stressful change into growth instead of withdrawal.
Existential courage and Yalom's four givens of existence
Irvin Yalom does not build his work around the word courage, but the idea fits closely with his. His Existential Psychotherapy (1980) organises the field around four givens: death, freedom, isolation and meaninglessness, set out in our guide to the four givens of existence. Each one corresponds roughly to a Tillich anxiety: death to the ontic, meaninglessness to the spiritual, and freedom, with its weight of responsibility, to the moral.
The shared move is facing these givens rather than defending against them. In this broad tradition, much ordinary suffering is understood as the cost of defences that keep death, freedom or aloneness out of view. Read loosely, existential courage is the name for the opposite: turning toward the givens and building a life with them in sight. Isolation, the given Tillich’s list does not cover directly, is treated in our page on existential isolation, the gap no relationship closes.
Staying in a job or leaving it: courage in an ordinary choice
Imagine a woman in her forties with a secure accounting job she finds empty. For years she has wanted to train as a teacher. Leaving means a smaller income, starting at the bottom, and the chance that she will fail, or succeed and find it no more meaningful.
Tillich’s three anxieties are all present. There is fate and death: she will not get these years back. There is emptiness: the old job no longer carries meaning, and the new one might not either. There is guilt: whichever she picks, she gives up a version of herself, and she may let down people who depend on her income.
Existential courage, in the sense of this tradition, does not decide the question for her. Staying can be courageous if she chooses it knowingly, owns it and stops treating it as something done to her. Leaving can be cowardly if it is a flight from the anxiety of staying. What marks courage is not the direction but that she makes the choice as her own while the anxiety is still there, instead of drifting until circumstance decides.
Does the language of existential courage blame people who struggle?
The strongest objection is moral. Calling acceptance of anxiety courage implies that not managing it is a failure of nerve, and that can read as blame toward people whose difficulties come from illness, poverty, trauma or injustice rather than from any lack of resolve. Critics also note that the ideal of the self-authoring individual reflects a particular culture and class, and that Tillich’s own resolution rests on religious faith that many readers do not share.
Defenders reply that the tradition separates existential anxiety, which belongs to everyone, from distress that needs care, and that courage in May’s sense is a capacity that relationships and support help to build, not a test anyone passes alone. Either way, an idea or a book sits alongside professional support, never in place of it. If you are in distress, please reach out to someone; in the US you can call or text 988.
The research base is thin. Tillich and May wrote philosophy and clinical reflection, not studies. Maddi’s hardiness work is the main empirical strand, and even there critics have questioned whether the hardiness scales measure something distinct from low neuroticism and how far the early findings generalise. Treat existential courage as a way of seeing, not a proven mechanism. Frankl’s related idea of saying yes to life despite pain, guilt and death is covered in our page on tragic optimism, and the moment when working answers collapse in our guide to what an existential crisis is.
Reading Tillich and May on existential courage in the original
Start with Tillich’s The Courage to Be. It is short, but dense: the chapters on being and anxiety and on the types of anxiety carry most of what this page summarises, and the closing theological chapter can be read separately. May’s The Courage to Create is the easier entry, an essay-length book whose first chapter sets out the kinds of courage. The Meaning of Anxiety is the place to see where his thinking on anxiety began.
For the therapeutic frame, Yalom’s Existential Psychotherapy places these ideas inside a full account of the givens; it is long, and our hub on existential therapy books suggests what to read before it. For hardiness, Maddi’s own papers and books are the primary sources.
Who coined the term existential courage?
No single person can be credited with the phrase, but its classic statement is Paul Tillich’s The Courage to Be (1952), which defines courage as self-affirmation in spite of non-being. Rollo May and later Salvatore Maddi used the idea in psychology.
What are Tillich's three types of anxiety?
Ontic anxiety about fate and death, spiritual anxiety about emptiness and meaninglessness, and moral anxiety about guilt and condemnation. Each has a relative form and an absolute form, and Tillich held that none can be removed, only faced.
Is existential courage the same as resilience?
They overlap but differ. Resilience usually means recovering from adversity. Existential courage is about affirming one’s life in the face of conditions that never go away, such as mortality. Maddi’s hardiness research sits between the two.
What kinds of courage did Rollo May describe?
In The Courage to Create (1975) May named physical, moral, social and creative courage, and treated creative courage, the bringing of new meaning into being, as the most important.
How does existential courage relate to Irvin Yalom?
Yalom organises existential therapy around four givens: death, freedom, isolation and meaninglessness. Existential courage is a fair name for facing those givens rather than defending against them, though Yalom does not make the term central.
Can existential courage help with anxiety?
It is a philosophical idea, not a treatment. It describes a stance toward the anxiety that belongs to being human. Anyone struggling with distress should look for professional support; reading sits alongside it.
Existential courage carries anxiety instead of curing it
Existential courage is the self-affirmation Tillich described: living and choosing while anxiety about death, meaninglessness and guilt remains. May widened it into physical, moral, social and creative forms; Maddi tried to measure it as hardiness; Yalom’s four givens give it a therapeutic frame. It is a contested and lightly researched idea, useful as a lens, and never a substitute for care.