What is liminality? Van Gennep’s threshold, Turner’s communitas and the Jungian use
Liminality is the threshold phase of a rite of passage: the stretch of time when a person has left one social status and has not yet been given the next.
The word comes from anthropology, not from psychology, and it had a precise job there before it became a general name for feeling stuck between two lives. This guide follows it from Arnold van Gennep in 1909, through Victor Turner in the 1960s, into Jungian writing on midlife and analysis, and out onto the internet, where liminal spaces now means a mood of empty corridors. Each of those uses is legitimate on its own terms, but they are not the same idea, and most confusion about the word comes from sliding between them.
Liminality (from Latin limen, threshold) is the middle phase of a rite of passage, between separation from an old status and incorporation into a new one. Arnold van Gennep named the pattern in Les Rites de Passage (1909); Victor Turner made the liminal phase a subject in its own right in the 1960s. Jungian writers later borrowed it for midlife and the analytic process.

- A phase, not a feeling In anthropology liminality is the middle of a structured ritual with a known before and after, usually run by elders.
- Two founders Van Gennep described the three-phase pattern in 1909; Victor Turner built the theory of the liminal phase, communitas and the liminoid.
- A borrowed term in Jungian writing Jung did not develop a theory of liminality; analysts such as Murray Stein applied Turner’s idea to midlife and to analysis.
- Liminal spaces are a third thing The internet aesthetic of empty malls and corridors borrows the word for an eerie mood, with no ritual and no exit.
Liminality is not just feeling in between
The loose modern sense of liminality is any transition: a move, a gap year, a divorce, waiting for test results, the week between Christmas and New Year. In that sense almost everything is liminal, which is why the word now appears in marketing copy and wellness posts as often as in anthropology journals. The original meaning is tighter. In a rite of passage the liminal phase is a recognised stage inside a ritual that a community runs on purpose. Someone is taken out of their old position, held apart for a time under the authority of people who know the procedure, and then brought back with a new position that everyone acknowledges. The middle has edges on both sides.
Three features separate that technical meaning from a vague sense of drift. First, there is a before and an after: the initiate knows, or the community knows, what status lies on the far side. Second, the passage is guided: elders, ritual specialists or older initiates hold the process and decide when it ends. Third, it is shared and public: the community recognises both the departure and the return. A private feeling of being unmoored, however real, lacks all three. That does not make the feeling unimportant, but calling it liminality borrows the prestige of a concept whose point was structure. This page sits in our guide to psychology concepts, and like several terms there, liminality is clearer once its origin is kept in view.
Van Gennep's threshold: the three phases of a rite of passage
The idea starts with Arnold van Gennep, a French ethnographer and folklorist, whose book Les Rites de Passage appeared in 1909. It was not translated into English until 1960, as The Rites of Passage, which is one reason the concept took off in English-language anthropology only in the 1960s. Van Gennep compared ceremonies from many societies around birth, puberty, marriage, death, entering a territory and joining a group, and argued that they share one underlying sequence.
- Separation (van Gennep’s preliminal rites): the person is detached from an earlier fixed point in the social structure, often marked by leaving home, cutting hair, removing clothing or a symbolic death.
- Transition (the liminal rites, from Latin limen, threshold): the person is in a marginal state, no longer what they were and not yet what they will be.
- Incorporation (postliminal rites): the person is brought back into the community in a new, stable position, with new rights and duties.
Van Gennep took the threshold image literally as well as figuratively. He noticed how often crossing a doorway, a gate or a border is ritualised, and treated the doorstep as the model for every social passage. He also noted that the weight of each phase varies: funerals stress separation, weddings stress incorporation, and initiations and pregnancies often give the transition phase the most elaborate treatment. What he did not do was write a theory of the middle phase itself. For him liminality was one part of a pattern, and the pattern was the discovery.
Victor Turner's betwixt and between, communitas and the liminoid
The British anthropologist Victor Turner, who did fieldwork among the Ndembu of what is now Zambia, turned van Gennep’s middle phase into a major idea. His essay “Betwixt and Between: The Liminal Period in Rites de Passage” first appeared in the mid-1960s and was collected in The Forest of Symbols (1967). There he described the people undergoing initiation as structurally invisible: they have lost the names, rank and property that defined them, they are often treated as if dead or not yet born, and they are associated with ambiguity, darkness, wilderness and the womb. Liminal persons, in Turner’s well-known phrase, are betwixt and between.
In The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure (1969) Turner added the idea for which he is best known: communitas. Ordinary social life, he argued, is structure, a system of differentiated positions. In the liminal phase those positions are suspended, and the initiates often experience an intense, egalitarian bond with one another, a sense of shared humanity stripped of rank. Communitas is the anti-structure that liminality makes room for. Turner thought societies need both, and that the alternation between structure and communitas is part of what keeps a society alive. He saw communitas outside ritual too, in pilgrimages, millenarian movements and some religious orders.
Turner was also the first to worry that his concept was spreading too far. In the 1970s, in the essay “Liminal to Liminoid, in Play, Flow, and Ritual” (later collected in From Ritual to Theatre, 1982), he proposed a second word, liminoid, for experiences in modern industrial societies that resemble liminality but differ in kind. Theatre, carnival, sport, art, festivals and leisure travel can produce liminal-like states, but they are optional, individual, often commercial, and they do not move anyone into a new social status. The same essay engages with Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi’s work on absorption, which is described on our page on the flow state. The distinction matters: a music festival may feel transformative, but you go home with the same job and the same legal status you had before.
An initiation rite followed through its liminal phase
The clearest way to see what the term originally meant is to follow a boys’ initiation of the kind Turner and others recorded, described here in general terms rather than as any one society’s rite. At the start, the boys are taken from their mothers’ households, often abruptly and sometimes with staged mourning, as if they were dying. Their hair may be shaved and their clothes removed. This is separation: they stop being children of particular homes.
They then live for weeks or months in a seclusion camp outside the village. They are given no personal names, wear the same simple coverings, obey the same instructors and undergo the same ordeals. Distinctions that mattered at home, such as whose father is a chief, are deliberately ignored. Elders teach them songs, rules, sacred knowledge and the meaning of masks and objects, and the boys often form bonds with each other that last for life. This is the liminal phase, and the bond is Turner’s communitas. Two things are worth noticing: the boys are not left to work out the meaning of their situation alone, and the whole community knows where they are and why.
Finally they return, often in a public ceremony, with new clothes, sometimes new names, and the rights of young men. They are incorporated. The point of the illustration is the shape: a threshold with a guard on each side and a known destination. Compare that with a modern adult who has lost a job and does not know what comes next. The second situation may feel more liminal, but in van Gennep’s and Turner’s terms it lacks the guidance, the shared recognition and the guaranteed exit that made the first one a rite.
Liminality in Jungian psychology: midlife, analysis and Hermes
Jung did not develop a theory of liminality, and the word does not belong to his core vocabulary. He did, however, write about passages: the turn from the first to the second half of life in his essay “The Stages of Life”, and the long process he called individuation, in which a person comes to terms with material from the unconscious. After Turner’s work became widely read, Jungian analysts found his vocabulary a good fit for those ideas, and liminality entered Jungian writing that way.
The best-known example is Murray Stein’s In Midlife: A Jungian Perspective (1983). Stein reads midlife as a liminal passage with the same three phases van Gennep described: a separation from the identity of early adulthood, often through loss or disillusion; a long liminal period in which the old persona no longer fits and nothing has replaced it; and, if things go well, a reintegration around a broader sense of self. Stein gives a central place to Hermes, the Greek god of boundaries, roads and crossings, who guided travellers and led souls to the underworld. Hermes, in this reading, is the figure who presides over thresholds, and a person in midlife meets him whether or not they know the myth. Readers who know Jung’s archetypes will recognise the move: a mythological figure used to describe a typical psychological situation.
Jungians also apply the idea to analysis itself. The consulting room is described as a protected space set apart from ordinary life, the analyst as something like the ritual elder who holds the frame, and the work as a passage in which old structures loosen before new ones form. Phenomena such as transference are sometimes read as part of that liminal field. Related experiences of a self coming apart, which Jungian writers describe in their own terms, are covered on our page on ego death. Note what the Jungian use keeps from Turner and what it changes. It keeps the three-phase shape and the idea of a guide. It moves the passage inside the individual, and it cannot promise the communal recognition that made a tribal initiation complete.
Reading about thresholds can help some people put words to a hard transition, but a concept is not a substitute for care. If a period of change has turned into crisis or overwhelming distress, talk to a professional. In the US you can call or text 988.
Anthropology, depth psychology and liminal spaces compared
| Anthropology | Depth psychology | Internet aesthetic | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key sources | Van Gennep (1909); Turner (1967, 1969) | Murray Stein, In Midlife (1983), and later Jungian writers | Online image communities from around 2019 |
| What is liminal | A person passing between social statuses | A person’s inner life during a major passage | A place, usually empty, or an image of one |
| Structure | Fixed ritual sequence with a before and an after | Three-phase shape borrowed as a map | None; a mood rather than a process |
| Who guides it | Elders and ritual specialists | The analyst, or the psyche itself | No one |
| How it ends | Public incorporation into a new status | Reintegration, if it comes, is private | It does not end; the image is the point |
| Typical example | An initiation seclusion camp | Midlife loss of an old identity | An empty mall at night, the Backrooms |
The third column deserves a fair word. The liminal spaces aesthetic that spread on Reddit, Twitter and image boards from around 2019 collects photographs of places built for transit or crowds and shown empty: hotel corridors, school hallways after hours, closed shopping malls, stairwells, waiting rooms. The best-known offshoot is the Backrooms, an image of endless yellow office rooms that grew into a collaborative horror fiction. These places are liminal in van Gennep’s literal sense of thresholds, spaces you pass through rather than stay in, and the unease they produce comes from seeing them without the people who give them a purpose. But nobody is initiated, nobody guides anyone, and there is no far side. The aesthetic borrows the word for a feeling, which is a reasonable use of language, not a claim about ritual.
Why liminality is now stretched to cover any uncertainty
Since the 1990s liminality has spread far beyond anthropology. Literary critics use it for characters and texts that sit between genres or worlds. In postcolonial theory Homi Bhabha’s The Location of Culture (1994) uses liminal and in-between spaces to describe how cultural identities are negotiated at their borders. Organisational researchers write about liminal workers such as consultants and temps; political scientists describe revolutions and pandemics as liminal moments for whole societies. Some of this work is careful and keeps the three-phase structure in view. Much of it uses liminal as a stylish synonym for transitional, ambiguous or uncertain.
The objection is the one Turner himself raised when he coined liminoid. If every uncertain state is liminal, the concept stops explaining anything, because the features that made it useful (the guide, the shared recognition, the known exit, the communitas) drop out. A more specific criticism concerns the modern self-help use, which can make a hard period sound meaningful by definition, as if every crisis were an initiation that will end in a better status. Van Gennep’s rites worked because a community arranged the ending. When no one arranges it, there is no guarantee that the passage leads anywhere. Psychologists who write about existential anxiety make a related point about uncertainty that has no ritual frame at all.
The defence of the wider use is also worth stating. Turner himself saw liminal and liminoid states as a source of creativity and social renewal, not only as a stage in tribal ritual, and he encouraged the extension to theatre, pilgrimage and modern culture. Modern societies have thinned out their rites of passage, so people meet thresholds without a ceremony to carry them across. A vocabulary that names those thresholds may be one of the few tools left. The fair conclusion is that the word travels well when the writer says which sense is meant, and badly when anthropology’s authority is borrowed for a mood.
Where to read about liminality in the original
Start with van Gennep’s The Rites of Passage in the 1960 English translation. The opening chapters, where he lays out the three-phase scheme and the territorial passage across a threshold, carry the argument; the long catalogue of examples that follows can be sampled. Then read Turner’s essay “Betwixt and Between” in The Forest of Symbols, which is short and the single best account of the liminal phase, followed by the chapters on liminality and communitas in The Ritual Process. For the Jungian application, Murray Stein’s In Midlife is the standard text and reads easily without much background. For the wider Jungian frame that Stein assumes, our guides to individuation and to the Jungian shadow are good companions.
What does liminality mean in simple terms?
It means being on a threshold: having left one stage or status and not yet entered the next. In anthropology it names the middle phase of a rite of passage, between separation and incorporation.
Who coined the term liminality?
Arnold van Gennep used liminal for the transition phase in Les Rites de Passage (1909). Victor Turner developed liminality into a full concept in the 1960s, in The Forest of Symbols (1967) and The Ritual Process (1969).
What is the difference between liminal and liminoid?
Turner used liminal for obligatory, communal ritual phases that move people into a new social status, and liminoid for optional, individual experiences in modern societies, such as theatre, festivals or travel, that feel similar but change nobody’s status.
What is communitas?
Communitas is Turner’s word for the intense, equal bond that forms among people in a liminal phase once ordinary rank and roles are suspended. He set it against structure, the normal system of social positions.
Did Jung write about liminality?
Not as a theory. Jung wrote about life stages and individuation, but liminality entered Jungian writing later, through analysts such as Murray Stein, whose In Midlife (1983) reads midlife as a liminal passage presided over by Hermes.
Are liminal spaces the same as liminality?
No. Liminal spaces is an internet aesthetic, popular from around 2019, of empty transit places such as corridors and closed malls. It borrows the word for an eerie mood; it has no ritual, no guide and no end point.
Liminality is a guided threshold with an exit, not a mood
Liminality began as the middle phase of van Gennep’s rites of passage and became, through Victor Turner, a theory of what happens when social structure is suspended: ambiguity, instruction and communitas, followed by a return in a new status. Jungian writers such as Murray Stein borrowed the shape for midlife and analysis, and the internet borrowed the word for empty corridors. All three uses are defensible, but they answer different questions, and Turner’s own distinction between liminal and liminoid is the best guard against using the word for every uncertain week.