Where to Start With Dostoevsky: The First Book, the Second, and Three to Leave for Later
Most people who give up on Dostoevsky gave up on the wrong book. The usual mistake is opening The Brothers Karamazov because it is the famous one, or The Double because it is short.
This page makes one decision for you: which Dostoevsky book to read first, which to read second, and which three to keep on the shelf until you already trust him. There are really only two good first books, and the right one depends on what kind of reader you are, not on which is greater.
Start with Crime and Punishment if you want a story that carries you; it is our default first Dostoevsky. Start with Notes from Underground instead if you want a short, strange test of whether his voice works on you, then read Crime and Punishment second. Do not begin with The Brothers Karamazov, The Idiot, Demons or The Double.
The first Dostoevsky book depends on which reader you are
Dostoevsky wrote five great novels and a handful of shorter works that matter, but only two of them work as a first meeting. If you want the whole career laid out year by year, with every title and the full six-book sequence, that is the job of our guide to reading Dostoevsky’s books in order. This page is the shorter decision: what to pick up tonight.
If you like a plot that pulls, start with Crime and Punishment (1866). A poor former student kills a pawnbroker to prove a theory about himself, and the rest of the novel is the theory falling apart under pressure from his own conscience and from one very patient investigator. It is long, but it is built like a thriller, and it teaches you how to read every Dostoevsky novel that follows. This is our default, and it matches the first step in the full reading order.
If you would rather find out quickly whether Dostoevsky is for you, start with Notes from Underground (1864). It runs under 150 pages, has almost no plot in its first half, and is narrated by one of the most irritating men in literature: a retired official who insists that people will act against their own interest just to prove they are free. Some readers find it thrilling and some find it unbearable. Either way, you will know within an evening, and you will have met the voice that the rest of his work grows out of.
Whichever of the two you start with, the other is your second book. Read Notes first and Crime and Punishment will feel like the same mind given a story to escape into. Read Crime and Punishment first and the Underground Man will be recognisable rather than baffling. The order between these two is a matter of temperament. The order after them is not, and that is where most first-time readers go wrong. Dostoevsky sits at the centre of our shelf of novels that therapists and their patients keep returning to, but only the later books, and only in the right sequence.
Crime and Punishment: the Dostoevsky to read first for the story
The reason Crime and Punishment works as a first book is that it gives you something to hold on to while Dostoevsky does what he always does: long scenes of people talking past each other, sudden violence, fever, and ideas that behave like characters. The murder happens early. After that the tension is not whether Raskolnikov will be caught but whether he will break, and the conversations with the investigator Porfiry Petrovich are some of the most gripping scenes in any novel.
It is over 500 pages in most editions, in six parts and an epilogue. Expect the first fifty pages to feel slow and the Russian names to confuse you; each character has a first name, a patronymic and one or two nicknames, and you will meet the same person under three of them. Keep a note of who is who for the first part and the problem disappears. The epilogue in Siberia divides readers. Some find it moving, some find it too tidy after so much chaos. Read it anyway; it is short.

Fyodor Dostoevsky, tr. Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky
The Vintage Classics edition in the Pevear and Volokhonsky translation, the same one our reading-order and translation guides recommend. It keeps the repetitive, feverish rhythm of Raskolnikov’s thinking that older versions tidied up. Over 500 pages, but the investigation keeps the pages turning. The trade-off: the prose is deliberately rougher than Garnett’s, and the Siberian epilogue still divides readers.
Notes from Underground: the short, strange way into Dostoevsky
Notes from Underground comes in two parts, and knowing that in advance saves a lot of first-time readers. Part One is the monologue: the narrator arguing with imagined critics about reason, free will and why he would rather be spiteful than sensible. It is dense, funny if you are in the mood, and exhausting if you are not. Part Two is a story, set years earlier, in which the same man humiliates himself at a dinner with old schoolmates and then treats a young woman cruelly because she was kind to him.
If Part One stalls you, do not abandon the book. Skim to Part Two, read it, and go back. The argument makes far more sense once you have watched the man act. This is also the book that existentialist readers treat as a starting point, which is why it turns up on lists of philosophical novels that ask what a life is for. Who it fails: a reader who needs a character to like. There is nobody to like here, and that is the point.

Fyodor Dostoevsky, tr. Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky
The Vintage Classics edition, translated by Pevear and Volokhonsky, under 150 pages. It is the cheapest way to find out whether Dostoevsky’s voice works for you and whether you like this translation before committing to a long novel. The trade-off: Part One is an argument, not a story, and some readers bounce off it. Skim ahead to Part Two if you stall.
Dostoevsky's books ranked as a first read, from best door to worst
The table below ranks his best-known books purely as a first Dostoevsky, which is a different question from which is greatest. The Brothers Karamazov is his masterpiece and sits near the bottom of this table for exactly that reason. White Nights (1848) is the gentlest way in of all: a short, tender story of a lonely dreamer over four nights in St Petersburg. It is lovely, but it does not show you the writer who made his name, so treat it as a rest between the big books rather than a test.
| Rank as a first read | Book and year | Length | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Crime and Punishment (1866) | Over 500 pages | Default first book: a plot that pulls you through the ideas |
| 2 | Notes from Underground (1864) | Under 150 pages | First if you want a one-evening test; otherwise read it second |
| 3 | White Nights (1848) | Short story | Gentle and tender, but not representative; best as a rest after the first two |
| 4 | The Idiot (1869) | Long novel | Leave for later: loose and digressive, needs trust in the author |
| 5 | Demons (1871 to 1872) | Long novel | Leave for later: slow comic opening, large cast, political |
| 6 | The Brothers Karamazov (1880) | Nearly 800 pages | His summit and his worst first book; read it last |
| 7 | The Double (1846) | Short novel | Early apprentice work; repetitive, and a poor sample of what he became |
Why The Brothers Karamazov should not be your first Dostoevsky
The Brothers Karamazov (1880) is the book people mean when they say Dostoevsky changed their life, so it is natural to want to start there. Do not. It is nearly 800 pages, it has a large cast and several long embedded set pieces, and it gathers up every theme from the earlier novels: the guilt of Crime and Punishment, the spite of the Underground Man, the holy fool of The Idiot, the political nihilism of Demons. Read cold, those set pieces feel like interruptions. Read after the others, they feel like the point.
The famous chapter, The Grand Inquisitor in Book Five, is a story Ivan tells his brother Alyosha about Christ returning during the Spanish Inquisition. It is often excerpted, and you can read it on its own as a taste. But the novel as a whole rewards a reader who already knows how Dostoevsky builds a scene, and that is what the first two books give you. Finished months before his death in early 1881, it is the place to end, not begin.
The Idiot, Demons and The Double: three Dostoevsky books to delay
The Idiot (1869) tries to put a truly good man, Prince Myshkin, into St Petersburg society and watches what it does to him. Its opening is wonderful, and it is his most personal novel: Myshkin’s epilepsy and the memory of standing before a firing squad are both taken from Dostoevsky’s own life, since he was put through a mock execution in 1849. But the middle of the book wanders, subplots stall, and a first-time reader has no reason yet to forgive that. Read it fourth or fifth.
Demons (serialised 1871 to 1872), also published in English as The Possessed and Devils, is about a small revolutionary cell in a provincial town. It is the funniest of the great novels until it suddenly becomes the darkest, but the comedy takes a long time to build, the first third is crowded with characters, and the satire lands far harder once you already know the Underground Man, because its radicals are his descendants. Some editions print a suppressed chapter, At Tikhon’s, as an appendix; read it where the translator suggests.
The Double (1846) is the trap for readers who want something short. A minor official meets a man identical to himself who slowly takes over his life. The idea is brilliant and it anticipates later fiction about split selves, but the execution is repetitive and imitative of Gogol, and early critics turned on it for good reason. Starting here is one of the most common ways people decide Dostoevsky is not for them. If you want short, take Notes from Underground or White Nights instead. The same logic keeps Poor Folk, his first novel, off the starting line.
Choosing a Dostoevsky translator: P&V, Garnett, McDuff, Ready, Katz
Translation matters more with Dostoevsky than with most novelists, because he wrote fast, repeated himself and let his characters interrupt their own sentences. The full comparison, with a described scene from Crime and Punishment in two versions, is on our page about which Dostoevsky translation to read. Here is the short version of how the main translators differ in feel.
Richard Pevear and Larissa Volokhonsky keep the roughness: the repetitions, the stops and restarts, the awkwardness that is part of how he writes. They are the modern standard, they come with useful notes, and they are what both editions on this page use. Constance Garnett translated nearly all of Dostoevsky about a century ago into smooth, fluent English. She reads easily, and she is what every free or unbranded edition reprints, but she irons out the differences between voices. David McDuff, in the Penguin Classics editions, is careful and close to the Russian, a little more formal in tone. Oliver Ready, whose Crime and Punishment Penguin published more recently, is livelier and more idiomatic, and brings out the dark comedy many readers miss. Michael Katz translated the Norton Critical Edition of Notes from Underground, a plain, readable version that comes with essays, which suits a student.
Our advice: if you have no preference, buy Pevear and Volokhonsky and stay with them across the books, so the voice stays consistent. If you have tried them and find them stiff, Ready’s Crime and Punishment is the best alternative for that novel. Avoid any edition that names no translator; it is almost always Garnett, uncredited, which is fine only if you chose her on purpose.
Why readers of psychology keep going back to Dostoevsky
Both first books are studies of a mind working against itself. Raskolnikov reasons his way into a murder and then cannot reason his way out of what he feels. The Underground Man knows exactly what would make him happier and refuses it out of pride. Freud wrote an essay on Dostoevsky in 1928, and the existentialists treated the Underground Man as an ancestor; you do not need either to enjoy the books, but it explains why they sit beside therapy novels on this site, and why our novels about psychiatrists and therapists keep circling the same territory.
If Dostoevsky works for you, the natural companion is Tolstoy, who asks the same questions about how to live in a calmer voice. Our page on where to start with Tolstoy makes the same first-book decision for him, and the Kafka reading order follows the line from the Underground Man into twentieth-century fiction about the trapped self. Irvin Yalom’s own Existential Psychotherapy treats freedom and responsibility as clinical questions, and readers who finish Notes from Underground will recognise its subject.
What is the best Dostoevsky book to start with?
Crime and Punishment for most readers, because its murder plot carries you through the ideas. If you want a short test first, Notes from Underground, under 150 pages, tells you in an evening whether his voice works for you.
Should I read Notes from Underground or Crime and Punishment first?
Either works, and you should read both as your first two. Choose Crime and Punishment if you want story, Notes from Underground if you want brevity and do not mind a narrator who argues more than he acts. Our reading-order guide puts Crime and Punishment first by default.
Can I start with The Brothers Karamazov?
You can, but it is the most common way to stall. It is nearly 800 pages and gathers themes from all his earlier novels. Read it last, after at least Crime and Punishment and Notes from Underground.
Is Crime and Punishment hard to read?
Less than its length suggests. It was written as a serial for a wide audience and built around an investigation, so it moves. The hardest part is the Russian names in the first fifty pages; once you know who is who, it reads quickly.
Which Dostoevsky translation should a beginner buy?
Pevear and Volokhonsky for most readers, and stay with them across books. Oliver Ready’s Crime and Punishment is a good, livelier alternative. Avoid editions that name no translator, which are almost always Constance Garnett uncredited.
Is The Double a good short introduction to Dostoevsky?
No. It is early work from 1846, repetitive and imitative, and a poor sample of the writer he became. For something short, read Notes from Underground or White Nights.
Dostoevsky in three moves: Crime and Punishment, Notes, then Karamazov
Read Crime and Punishment first if you want a story, or Notes from Underground first if you want a short test, and read the other one second. Keep The Idiot, Demons and The Brothers Karamazov for later, skip The Double as a starting point, and pick one translator, Pevear and Volokhonsky by default, before you begin.