The trickster archetype explained: Jung’s essay, the living myths and the critics

Explained

The trickster archetype is the shape-shifting, rule-breaking figure of myth who steals, lies, blunders and, often by accident, makes something new. In Jungian psychology the idea comes from one essay, Jung's commentary on a Native American trickster cycle published in 1956.

Most of what circulates online under the name has drifted a long way from that essay. The trickster gets treated as a villain, as a personality type you can be sorted into, or as a synonym for the comic Jester of brand strategy. This guide starts by clearing those away, then sets out what Jung actually argued, introduces the figures themselves with some care for the traditions they belong to, and ends with the serious objections anthropologists have raised to the whole Jungian reading.

Quick answer

The trickster archetype is a mythic figure who crosses boundaries through cunning, appetite and mischief, both disrupting order and creating it. Jung described it in his essay On the Psychology of the Trickster-Figure, written for Paul Radin’s The Trickster (1956), as a collective shadow figure that mirrors an earlier, undifferentiated state of consciousness. It is a pattern in stories, not a personality type.

The trickster archetype explained: Jung's essay, the living myths and the critics

What the trickster archetype is not: villain, type or Jester

Three misreadings to set aside first
  • Not a villain. The trickster does harm, but rarely from settled malice. In many stories the same figure who causes chaos also brings fire, light, stories or food to people. Calling the trickster “the evil one” turns an ambiguous figure into a moral one, which is exactly what the myths refuse to do.
  • Not a personality type or a quiz result. Jung never offered the trickster as a category of person, and nothing in his essay supports a test that tells you whether you are one. An archetype in his sense is a pattern of imagination that shows up in myths, dreams and behaviour, not a label for a temperament.
  • Not the brand Jester. The Jester is one of the twelve types in Margaret Mark and Carol S. Pearson’s marketing book The Hero and the Outlaw (2001). It stands for fun, irreverence and lightness. The mythic trickster can be funny, but it is also greedy, obscene, dangerous and sacred, and it belongs to religious traditions, not to a positioning exercise.

Keeping these apart matters because the popular versions borrow the trickster’s prestige while dropping its strangeness. The figure that Jung wrote about, and that anthropologists have spent a century recording, is uncomfortable on purpose. The trickster sits with the other ideas in this site’s collection of psychology concepts explained, and within Jung’s own system it belongs among the figures described in the guide to Jungian psychology concepts, closest of all to the shadow.

Jung's trickster essay and Paul Radin's Winnebago cycle

Where the Jungian idea comes from

The source is a single book. In 1956 the American anthropologist Paul Radin published The Trickster: A Study in American Indian Mythology, built around the trickster cycle of the Winnebago people of Wisconsin and Nebraska, who today call themselves the Ho-Chunk. Radin presented the cycle itself, with his own commentary, and the volume included two further essays: one by the classical scholar Karl Kerényi on tricksters in Greek myth, and one by Jung, titled On the Psychology of the Trickster-Figure.

Jung’s essay is short and later went into volume 9, part 1 of his Collected Works, The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, alongside his papers on the mother, the child and the rebirth archetypes. It is not one of his long works, and it is a commentary on another scholar’s material rather than a theory built from his own clinical cases. That context is worth holding on to, because later popular writing often treats the trickster as if it were as central to Jung as the shadow or the anima. It is not; it is a figure he wrote about once, at length, late in his career.

The Winnebago trickster in Radin’s cycle is a startling character. He wanders, eats, sleeps with whomever he can, is fooled as often as he fools, and does not yet seem to know where his own body ends: in one well-known episode his right and left arms fight each other. Over the course of the cycle he slowly gains a little order and purpose, and by the end he does things that benefit people. Radin read this arc as a picture of growing awareness, and Jung took up that reading.

How Jung read the trickster as a collective shadow

An image of an earlier state of consciousness

Jung’s central claim is that the trickster is a collective shadow figure: a summing up of the inferior, uncontrolled and unadapted traits that a culture has pushed out of its conscious self-image. Where the personal shadow, as the guide to the Jungian shadow explains, holds what one individual disowns, the trickster holds what a whole people has grown past or wants to have grown past. Telling and laughing at the stories keeps that material in view without letting it rule.

He also read the figure historically. For Jung the trickster pictured an earlier, undifferentiated state of consciousness, a mind not yet split cleanly into conscious and unconscious, human and animal, self and world. The arms that fight each other are, on this reading, an image of a psyche that has not yet become one thing. The trickster is half animal and half god, foolish and clever, and Jung saw in that mixture something close to how the unconscious itself behaves.

To show that the pattern was not only Native American, Jung pointed to European parallels. He wrote about the medieval feasts of misrule, such as the Feast of Fools, in which clergy turned church ritual upside down for a day, electing a mock bishop and parodying the liturgy. He also connected the trickster with the alchemists’ Mercurius, a slippery, shape-changing spirit he wrote about elsewhere, and with the mischief that folklore attributes to poltergeists. His point was that Europeans still had trickster material, but had pushed it into carnival, folklore and the margins of religion.

Two further ideas in the essay are often missed. Jung suggested that the trickster’s disorder carries a seed of something better: in its blundering it anticipates a figure who saves or heals. And he treated the shadow as something that becomes more dangerous the more it is forgotten, so the old stories had a protective function. Both points feed the modern practice described in the guide to shadow work, though Jung himself offered no such method.

Hermes, Loki, Coyote, Raven, Anansi and Eshu

Six figures from traditions that are not interchangeable

The figures usually grouped as tricksters come from very different cultures, and several of them belong to traditions that are still practised and told today. They share family resemblances, such as cunning, hunger, shape-shifting and a habit of crossing lines, but they are not the same character in different costumes. The table below is a starting point, not a summary of any tradition.

FigureTraditionA story often toldWhat is distinctive
HermesAncient GreekIn the Homeric Hymn to Hermes he steals Apollo’s cattle on the day he is born and invents the lyreA god of roads, boundaries, messengers, thieves and the passage of souls to the underworld
LokiNorse, recorded mainly in medieval Icelandic sourcesHis part in the death of the god BaldrShape-shifter who helps and then betrays the gods; his place in the myths turns darker over time
CoyoteMany Native American peoples, especially of the West and the PlainsStories differ by nation; Coyote often both shapes the world and makes a fool of himselfGreedy and foolish, yet sometimes a creator or culture hero
RavenPeoples of the Pacific Northwest Coast, such as the Tlingit and HaidaRaven steals the sun or daylight and releases it into the worldAppetite and trickery that end up giving people light
AnansiAkan peoples of West Africa, carried to the Caribbean and the AmericasAnansi wins the stories of the world from the sky godA spider who outwits the stronger through wit; the stories became a lasting thread in the African diaspora
EshuYoruba religion of West Africa and its diaspora religionsEshu walks between two friends wearing a hat of a different colour on each side, and they quarrel over itAn orisha of crossroads and communication, still honoured in living practice; calling him only a trickster is reductive
Six figures commonly called tricksters

The last row shows why care is needed. Eshu is a deity worshipped today in West Africa and in religions of the Americas such as Candomblé and Santería, where he is known under related names. For practitioners he is a messenger who opens and closes ways, not a character in a comparative mythology chart. The same caution applies to Coyote and Raven: the stories belong to specific nations, are told in specific settings, and in some communities have rules about who may tell them and when. A general article can point to them; it cannot speak for them.

Hermes and Loki are different in kind because the religions they belonged to ended long ago and the myths survive mainly as literature. That is one reason the trickster idea in Europe often runs through them. It is also why a reader should be wary of any list that puts all six side by side as if they were one archetype wearing local dress: the resemblance is real, but so are the differences in what each figure means to the people who tell the stories.

Lewis Hyde and the trickster as boundary-crosser

The best general book on the figure

For a reader who wants one book on tricksters, the usual recommendation is Lewis Hyde’s Trickster Makes This World (1998). Hyde is a poet and essayist rather than a Jungian, and he does not treat the trickster as a stage of consciousness. Instead he reads the figure as a boundary-crosser: the one who moves across the lines a culture draws between sacred and profane, clean and dirty, honest and dishonest, and in doing so shows where those lines are and that they could be drawn differently.

Hyde’s book works closely with Hermes, Coyote, Raven, Eshu and others, and then follows the pattern into modern artists and writers who unsettle the categories of their time. Its strength is that it keeps the trickster strange and creative rather than reducing it to a psychological symptom. It also shows how the figure relates to liminality, the in-between condition of thresholds and rites of passage, since the trickster is in effect a personification of the threshold.

The trickster beside Jung's hero, shadow and other archetypes

How the figure fits the wider system

The trickster makes most sense in contrast with the hero. Jung’s hero, as the guide to the hero archetype describes, is an image of the ego fighting its way free of the unconscious. The trickster is what consciousness looks like before that fight has been won, or what slips back in once it has. The Winnebago cycle can even be read as a trickster slowly turning toward the role of culture hero, which is one reason Radin and Jung saw development in it.

Popular archetype systems blur these figures. The twelve types discussed in the guide to male archetypes include a Jester and a Magician, either of which gets called a trickster online, and the lists in the guide to female archetypes show how few of the famous mythic tricksters are female. Those systems are useful for what they set out to do, but they are later inventions, and none of them reproduces what Jung meant by the trickster.

The case against Jung's reading of the trickster

What anthropologists and scholars of religion object to

The most serious objection is that Jung’s reading treats Native American material as a picture of a primitive stage of the human mind. Calling the Winnebago trickster an image of an earlier, undifferentiated consciousness places the people who told the stories at the bottom of a ladder that ends with modern Europeans. Radin’s own framing leaned the same way. Many later anthropologists regard this as a holdover of nineteenth-century evolutionary thinking about cultures, and it is hard to defend today.

A second objection is that the archetype lumps together figures from unrelated traditions. Scholars of religion have argued that “trickster” is a category built by Western researchers, and that it makes Hermes, Eshu and Coyote look more alike than their own traditions would allow. A deity honoured in living worship and a character in a winter storytelling cycle are not the same kind of thing, and grouping them under one psychological heading can erase what each means locally.

A third, more general objection applies to Jung’s archetypes as a whole: similarity between stories does not prove an inherited pattern in the psyche, since shared human situations, contact between peoples and the selection choices of the researcher can all produce resemblance. Defenders reply that Jung’s reading can be taken as one lens among several, and that his point about the shadow-like role of disorder in a culture does not depend on ranking cultures. Both positions are worth knowing; the fair summary is that the trickster is a real and widespread pattern in story, while Jung’s explanation of it is an interpretation with clear historical blind spots.

A reading path for the trickster figure

From the original essay to the best modern book
  1. Paul Radin, The Trickster: A Study in American Indian Mythology (1956). The Winnebago cycle itself, with Radin’s commentary and the essays by Kerényi and Jung. Read the cycle before the commentaries.
  2. C. G. Jung, On the Psychology of the Trickster-Figure. Also in volume 9, part 1 of the Collected Works, so readers with that volume do not need the Radin book to reach Jung’s argument.
  3. Lewis Hyde, Trickster Makes This World (1998). The best general book, readable, wide-ranging and not tied to Jung.
  4. Collections of the stories from the traditions themselves, preferably edited or told by members of those communities, before any comparative theory.

Readers new to Jung will find the trickster essay easier after one of the general books suggested in the guide to Carl Jung books for beginners, since it assumes the reader already knows what Jung meant by the shadow and the collective unconscious.

Frequently Asked Questions
What is the trickster archetype in simple terms?

It is the mythic figure who breaks rules and crosses boundaries through cunning, appetite and mischief, often causing chaos and creating something new in the same story. In Jungian psychology it is read as a collective shadow figure.

Where did Jung write about the trickster?

In the essay On the Psychology of the Trickster-Figure, written as a commentary for Paul Radin’s The Trickster: A Study in American Indian Mythology (1956). The essay is also in volume 9, part 1 of Jung’s Collected Works.

Is the trickster evil?

No. The trickster does harm and breaks taboos, but in many traditions the same figure brings light, fire or stories to people. It is ambiguous rather than evil, which is much of its point.

Is the trickster the same as the Jester archetype?

No. The Jester is a brand and self-help type from Mark and Pearson’s twelve-archetype system (2001). The mythic trickster is older, darker and tied to religious traditions; the two overlap only in their humour.

Who are the best-known trickster figures?

Commonly cited figures include Hermes in Greek myth, Loki in Norse myth, Coyote and Raven in Native American traditions, Anansi in Akan stories and Eshu in Yoruba religion. Each belongs to its own tradition and should not be treated as a local version of one character.

Why do anthropologists criticise Jung's view of the trickster?

Mainly because it treats Native American stories as evidence of a primitive stage of the mind, and because it groups unrelated figures under one Western category. Many scholars accept the pattern in story while rejecting that explanation.

Conclusion

The trickster is a pattern in living stories, not a type to be

The trickster archetype names a real and widespread figure in myth: the boundary-crosser who disrupts and creates in the same breath. Jung’s 1956 essay reads it as a collective shadow and an image of early consciousness, a reading that still illuminates why cultures make room for licensed disorder, but that ranks cultures in a way few scholars now accept. Read Radin’s cycle and Hyde’s book, respect the traditions the figures come from, and treat any trickster quiz with suspicion.